Skip to content

Review Roundup: BILLY ELLIOT THE MUSICAL at the Sunderland Empire

Annette McLaughlin (Mrs Wilkinson), William Gurney (Billy) and the company in Billy Elliot the Musical. Photo by Tristram Kenton The reviews are in for Billy Elliot the Musical, which has opened its new UK and Ireland tour at the Sunderland Empire, the nearest big theatre to the County Durham pit villages where the story is set. Stephen Daldry directs again, with Elton John’s score, Lee Hall’s book and lyrics, and Peter Darling’s choreography. The North East critics are unanimous: all six who rate it give five stars. They single out press-night Billy William Gurney above all, along with Harper Etienne’s Michael, Deka Walmsley’s Dad and the duet with original Billy Liam Mower. The tour reaches the Adelphi Theatre in the West End on 12 February 2027.

5.0 / 5 from 6 criticsThe verdict: ten reviews so far, and the six critics who give a rating all give five stars, an average of 5.0 out of 5. British Theatre Guide, the Sunderland Echo, The Northern Echo and In Newcastle publish no score, but none of them is any cooler. Every notice singles out press-night Billy William Gurney, and most find room for Harper Etienne’s Michael, Deka Walmsley’s Dad and the duet with original Billy Liam Mower. The only blemish anyone reports is a technical fault that briefly halted Electricity, and three critics say the company handled it without missing a beat.

What are critics saying about Billy Elliot the Musical?

Chronicle Live

"Billy Elliot is back in Sunderland and is THE best show you'll see in 2026"

Reviewer: Simon Duke

Simon Duke goes further than anyone, arguing that this staging is even stronger than the one Sunderland saw a decade ago. He reserves particular praise for the company as a whole.

"quite possibly, one of the best ensembles I've ever had the pleasure of seeing on any stage anywhere"

He calls Annette McLaughlin’s Mrs Wilkinson a performance that stands on its own rather than in the shadow of the film, and says the closing number left him close to tears.

Read Simon Duke’s full review at Chronicle Live

Shields Gazette

"A breathtaking triumph that makes the region proud"

Reviewer: Nicole Mavin

Nicole Mavin says five stars undersell it and that she would give six if she could. Gurney is the centre of her review.

"At the heart of it all is William Gurney, whose portrayal of Billy Elliot is simply mesmerising."

She reports the brief stoppage during Electricity and argues it made the restarted number land harder, then turns to Etienne’s scene-stealing Michael and a set that changes location without ever pulling focus.

Read Nicole Mavin’s full review in the Shields Gazette

Deka Walmsley (Dad) and William Gurney (Billy) in Billy Elliot the Musical. Photo by Tristram Kenton

The Reviews Hub

"Welcome Back Billy!"

Reviewer: Jonathan Cash

Jonathan Cash credits the returning original team, from Stephen Daldry’s direction to Peter Darling’s choreography and Ian MacNeil’s set, and finds the show as funny as it is moving.

"This triumphant production marks a worthy and welcome return for this funny, moving and ultimately joyous musical"

He picks out Walmsley’s grief-stricken Dad and Lesley Joseph’s Grandma, and calls the instant standing ovation fully earned.

Read Jonathan Cash’s full review at The Reviews Hub

Cultured North East

"Back on home ground after a decade away, Billy Elliot delivers a five-star reminder of why this North East story has conquered the world"

Reviewer: Sam Wonfor

Sam Wonfor has followed the show since its West End rehearsals in 2005 and writes as someone it has undone more than once. Twenty years on, she says, it still works on her.

"Two decades after I first saw it, Billy Elliot can still make me laugh until my face hurts"

She singles out the Angry Dance against the riot shields and the duet with Mower, and reads the Sunderland ovation as an expression of regional pride.

Read Sam Wonfor’s full review at Cultured North East

William Gurney (Billy) and Liam Mower (Older Billy) in Billy Elliot the Musical. Photo by Tristram Kenton

Northern Arts Review

"It has everything you want from a musical"

Reviewer: Kay Wilson

Kay Wilson was seeing the show for the first time, and it went straight onto her list of all-time favourites.

"it was quite simply one of the best shows I’ve ever seen in a theatre"

She is struck by the contrast between the ballet girls and the police lines in the strike scenes, praises young Lola Cant and Etienne for their comic timing, and says the five stars ought to be solid gold.

Read Kay Wilson’s full review at Northern Arts Review

Palatinate

"heartbreak and hope held in the same breath"

Reviewer: Anna Pile

Anna Pile, also a first-timer, writes about the craft as much as the story: MacNeil’s rooms gliding in from the wings, Paul Arditti’s sound design and the giant Thatcher puppet.

"Every decision felt like a line in a love letter to Durham and, by extension, the whole of the North East"

She ranks Gurney’s first-act finale among the best sequences she has seen on stage, and credits Walmsley with carrying the emotional weight of the evening.

Read Anna Pile’s full review at Palatinate

Spencer Collins (Billy) and Lesley Joseph (Grandma) in Billy Elliot the Musical. Photo by Tristram Kenton

British Theatre Guide

Reviewer: Meena Green

Meena Green thinks the show balances Billy’s ballet story against the strike well, with the lighter scenes between the children never far away when it turns sad.

"There are a few emotional moments throughout the show that caused audience members—myself included—to cry…"

She praises the three young leads in turn, Etienne’s singing and tap work especially, and calls it a must-see while it is in Sunderland.

Read Meena Green’s full review at British Theatre Guide

Sunderland Echo

"I laughed, I cried"

Reviewer: Katy Wheeler

Katy Wheeler hears in the opening miners’ number something that speaks directly to an audience whose families lived through the strike, and she does not hold back on the superlatives.

"Brace yourself for the best piece of theatre you’re likely to see all year."

She enjoys the potty-mouthed ballet class and Merry Christmas Maggie Thatcher, and was on her feet for the ovation.

Read Katy Wheeler’s full review in the Sunderland Echo

Rafferty Smale (Billy), Annette McLaughlin (Mrs Wilkinson) and the company in Billy Elliot the Musical. Photo by Tristram Kenton

The Northern Echo

"Billy Elliot at the Empire is a spectacular homecoming that does the North East proud"

Reviewer: Olivia Howlett

Olivia Howlett admires how calmly Gurney picked up Electricity after the stoppage, and finds a real sense of camaraderie running through the company.

"a production that has everything: outstanding performances, music that moves you, comedy that has the audience roaring…"

Joseph’s Grandma and Etienne’s Michael are her other highlights.

Read Olivia Howlett’s full review in The Northern Echo

In Newcastle

Reviewer: Joanna Andrews

Joanna Andrews calls Gurney the star of the show beyond doubt and admits his dancing made her cry more than once. She also has warm words for Jack Bandeira’s Tony and for Joseph.

"Because theatre doesn’t get much more moving, more exhilarating or more memorable than this."

She notes a couple of minor technical hiccups and praises the cast for riding them out.

Read Joanna Andrews’s full review at In Newcastle

The company in Billy Elliot the Musical. Photo by Tristram Kenton

For the first look at the tour, see our production photos of all four Billys. For more roundups from beyond London, see what the critics made of The Scouse Nativity: The Second Coming at Liverpool’s Royal Court and the RSC’s First Encounters: Julius Caesar in Stratford-upon-Avon.

Billy Elliot the Musical is at the Sunderland Empire until 28 November, then tours to Manchester and Edinburgh before opening at the Adelphi Theatre on 12 February 2027, booking until 31 July 2027.