The notices are in for The Scouse Nativity: The Second Coming, Liverpool’s Royal Court’s revival of its 2017 festive hit, nine years on. Kevin Fearon’s retelling of the Christmas story, pitched at audiences of 16 and over and now directed by Nicole Behan, sends a trainee angel to steer Mary and Joseph past a scheming department-store Herod, to a soundtrack of pop covers. Most of the critics had a riotous night, and the warmest words go to the company’s comic timing, Lindzi Germain’s angel and Mark Walters’ revolving pop-up storybook set. Where they part company is on pace, and one critic found Herod’s pursuit of Mary hard to laugh at in the week it opened.
4.3 / 5 from 7 criticsThe verdict: nine reviews so far. Three give it five stars, three give it four and one gives it three, while British Theatre Guide and Northern Soul publish no rating. Across the seven that score it, the average is 4.3 out of 5. Nearly everyone praises the cast’s comic timing and Mark Walters’ revolving storybook set. Where the critics part company is on pace: West End Best Friend, Theatre and Tonic and the Wirral Globe all feel it slackens, the second act especially, and Northern Soul found Herod’s storyline uncomfortable viewing in the week it opened.
What are critics saying about The Scouse Nativity: The Second Coming?
The Reviews Hub
"Laugh out Loud"
Reviewer: Gill Lewis
Gill Lewis finds the Royal Court regulars on top form and plainly enjoying themselves, and credits their comic timing with bringing Fearon’s script to life.
"a gloriously ridiculous retelling of the traditional Christmas Nativity through a distinctly Scouse lens"
She singles out Walters’ revolving storybook set, which she thinks becomes part of the comedy itself, and judges the pacing and the mix of songs just right.
A Young(ish) Perspective
"A night well worthy of being described as sound"
Reviewer: Tim Boey
Tim Boey thinks the revival lives up to the 2017 original and sharpens its humour.
"retelling the familiar story with a greater injection of clever wit, humour, and exceptional musical direction"
He praises Lindzi Germain’s motherly angel and Paul Duckworth’s relish as the villain, and rates the vocals of Germain and Jess Smith highly, though he warns parents that some of the jokes are not for younger ears.

Stagey Reviews
"This year, it’s a cracker!"
Stagey Reviews admires how closely each part has been written around the strengths of a company of Royal Court favourites, from the vocals of Jess Smith and Adam McCoy to the comic trio of Keddy Sutton, Lenny Wood and Helen Carter.
"this year’s production truly sleighs and is right as rein(deer)"
The review also credits Walters’ pop-up storybook set, Zoë Murdoch’s costumes and Ben Gladwin’s musical direction, and urges readers to book before it sells out.
Liverpool Echo
"Liverpool's Scouse Nativity is absolutely bonkers - but in the best way"
Reviewer: Hannah Rees
Hannah Rees revels in the chaos, from Lindzi Germain appearing suspended above the stage to the moments when the cast struggle to keep a straight face.
"it's definitely a go-to night out for anyone looking for something fun this Christmas"
She recommends it as a grown-up Christmas tradition, thick with local references and daft set pieces.

West End Best Friend
"Buckets of heart"
Reviewer: Lauren Wilson
Lauren Wilson enjoys the local jokes and Gladwin’s eclectic song choices, and says every member of the small cast shines, with Keddy Sutton’s timing the standout.
"Fearon and Behan pull it off with plenty of pizazz. Fearon’s writing is very funny"
Her one reservation is a reality-TV detour in the later stretch that stalls the momentum before the finale; otherwise she calls it a triumph and a team effort.
Wirral Globe
"Scouse-flavoured Angel Delight"
Reviewer: Peter Grant
Peter Grant, who saw the 2017 original, finds the show has kept its zest, though he notes a slower pace, fewer gags and surprisingly few topical jokes this time round.
"Paul Duckworth returns as the mad as a bag-of-frogs ruler with manic stares to out-do Paddington Bear."
He enjoys the high-energy dance numbers, the pop-up book set and the shepherd trio’s rapid costume changes.

Theatre and Tonic
"Undoubtedly theatre made for Liverpool and for Liverpudlians"
Reviewer: Seana
Coming to a Royal Court Christmas show for the first time, Seana describes an evening with most of a pantomime’s ingredients, aimed squarely at adults.
"it’s all the best parts of a pantomime, catered to the humour of the grown-ups…"
She picks out Adam McCoy’s Joseph, but feels the second act loses its way once the birth has closed the first, with Herod’s continuing pursuit hard to follow. She still calls the night a scream.
British Theatre Guide
"A lot of fun from beginning to end"
Reviewer: David Chadderton
David Chadderton notes that the show is an adult pantomime in all but name, and enjoys Paul Duckworth’s Herod as a master of disguise, Behan’s slick direction and the revolving set.
"It's all very silly and some of the jokes are older than me, but it looks and sounds great"
He also singles out the singing of Jess Smith, Adam McCoy and Lindzi Germain.
Read David Chadderton’s full review at British Theatre Guide

Northern Soul
"Just didn’t feel very funny"
Reviewer: Fran Yeoman
Fran Yeoman files the coolest notice. Watching Herod pursue Mary in a week of headlines about powerful men, she found the storyline hard to laugh at, while making clear that this is no fault of Duckworth’s performance.
"pretty much exactly what you would expect from the Royal Court’s mammoth festive run"
She enjoys McCoy’s Britney Spears number and Walters’ storybook set, and reports an audience that seemed happy with what it came for.
For more roundups from beyond London, see what the critics made of the RSC’s First Encounters: Julius Caesar in Stratford-upon-Avon, and closer to home, the Orange Tree Theatre’s Cranford.
The Scouse Nativity: The Second Coming is booking at Liverpool’s Royal Court until 16 January 2027.
For more information, visit the official website.








