
The reviews are in for Cranford, the new stage version of Elizabeth Gaskell's 1853 novel that Lin Coghlan and Shaun McKenna have adapted for the Orange Tree Theatre, with Josh Roche directing in the round and Tamsin Greig leading the cast as Matty Jenkyns. The notices are warm, though not unanimous. Most of the critics found it very funny and quietly moving, and nearly all of them single out Greig, with Alexandra Gilbreath, Phoebe Pryce and Saffron Dey also earning mentions. The dissent comes from BroadwayWorld, which thinks the adaptation laughs at its women too often and leaves Gaskell's darker themes as footnotes.
4.4 / 5 from 8 criticsThe verdict: nine reviews so far. Four give it five stars, three give it four and one gives it three, and Mark Aspen publishes no rating. Across the eight that score it, the average is 4.4 out of 5. Almost everyone praises Tamsin Greig's Matty and an ensemble that works as a true company. Where the critics part company is on tone: most find the comedy and the grief well balanced, while BroadwayWorld thinks the production too often plays the women for laughs.
What are critics saying about Cranford?
The Arts Desk
"Mrs Gaskell's world brought vividly to life"
Reviewer: Gary Naylor
Gary Naylor calls Coghlan, McKenna and Roche the leading adapters of classic English novels working today. In his view they cut the book where it needs cutting and end up with something concise and clear.
"a cast that looks impressive on paper and is simply magnificent on stage."
He thinks Greig's performance is built on the smallest gestures, and he picks out Saffron Dey's Martha as a standout. He also notes that the comedy never mocks the women.
The Reviews Hub
"Proper funny"
The Reviews Hub's critic was impressed by how neatly the adaptation ties Gaskell's episodic stories into one piece. They also note that it never feels rushed, despite a running time of almost two and a half hours.
"…a gloriously funny production that is a joy from start to finish."
Greig is called exceptional, and the review enjoys watching her Matty grow in confidence. It says the cast feels at home together and that the in-the-round space suits a story about a close-knit community.

LondonTheatre1
Reviewer: Chris Omaweng
Chris Omaweng admits that some of it is hammy. Even so, he says the evening held his attention from start to finish, and you do not need to know the novel to follow it.
"A phenomenal cast and crisp direction combine to provide an equally hilarious and thoughtful theatrical experience."
He enjoys the subplot around the maid Martha and the brisk scene changes on a nearly bare stage. He also likes how the production makes use of the space while the building is being redeveloped around it.
All That Dazzles
Reviewer: Ruth Sealey
Ruth Sealey calls the use of the round one of the best she has seen. She says the comedy and the sadness are judged so well that neither diminishes the other.
"as an ensemble, the cast is quite frankly exceptional, with each character developing into a distinct individual"
Her highlight is Alexandra Gilbreath's Miss Pole, but she names Phoebe Pryce's Eliza as the standout. She also praises Max Pappenheim's music and warns readers not to mistake the humour for mockery.

Theatre Weekly
"A suitably warming affair for the midwinter months"
Reviewer: Maggie O'Shea
Maggie O'Shea recommends it to anyone who wants some Christmas cheer without a pantomime. She feels the long comic sequences in the first act sometimes stray from the story, and that the second act is the stronger one.
"his staging is unshowy but dynamic and clever, making the most of every iota of space."
She describes Greig's comic timing as second to none, and her performance as touchingly vulnerable. The word she lands on for the whole evening is cosy.
The Spy in the Stalls
"A sheer delight"
Reviewer: Jonathan Evans
Jonathan Evans enjoys the laughs and the quirky residents, and he thinks the second half brings out how complex these people really are. He finds the narrator role is not entirely necessary, and that the closing message is a little mawkish and overstated.
"It’s a mad mad mad world that the extraordinary ensemble cast have drawn us into."
Even so, he calls the ending heartwarming, and he admits the audience left grinning.

London Living Large
Reviewer: J.C.
J.C. notes that the adaptation reshapes some of Gaskell's incidents for a modern audience but keeps the character of the novel intact. The simple staging, in this view, keeps attention on the characters as they change.
"succeeds in balancing the comedy of Cranford's rituals with the complex emotional lives that lie beneath them."
The review praises Greig's journey from timid deference to independence, as well as Abigail Cruttenden's pair of contrasting roles.
BroadwayWorld
"The team behind The Forsyte Saga return to adapt Elizabeth Gaskell's Northern rural classic"
Reviewer: Clementine Scott
Clementine Scott admires Greig and the comic actresses around her. Her objection is that too much of the running time turns the women into figures of fun, and that the class and colonial themes barely make it to the stage.
"much of what could be interesting here dances tantalisingly beneath the surface."
She thinks both the direction and the drama improve in the second act, but the change of tone is hard to pull off after so much mockery.

Mark Aspen
"Propensity to Propriety"
Reviewer: Gill Martin
Gill Martin calls it a perfect period choice for Christmas. She credits the sharp writing and Roche's direction for a fast, joke-packed evening that swings from the hilarious to the tragic.
"There isn’t a dry eye in the house . . . but mainly through tears of laughter."
She praises the three actors who share the male roles between them, especially Jonny Glynn, who plays a cleric, a magician and a long-lost brother.
For a first look at the production, see our Cranford production photos, and for the full company, our report on Sara Crowe and Alexandra Gilbreath joining Tamsin Greig.
Cranford is booking at the Orange Tree Theatre until 16 January 2027.
For more information, visit the official website.








