
The reviews are in for Sylvia, the Old Vic and ZooNation musical about Sylvia Pankhurst, which ends its 2026 UK tour with five performances at the Royal Albert Hall on 13-15 November. Kate Prince wrote the book with Priya Parmar and directs and choreographs, to a hip-hop, funk and soul score by Josh Cohen and DJ Walde. Beverley Knight returns as Emmeline Pankhurst and Naomi Katiyo plays Sylvia. Thirteen critics have filed on the London run. Nearly all praise Knight, most praise Katiyo, and most admire the choreography. The split is over the material: Theatre Weekly and JADAR find the score repetitive and the writing thin, while several critics say the hall swallows some of the lyrics.
4.3 / 5 from 10 criticsThe verdict: thirteen reviews of the London run. Four give it five stars, four give it four, one gives it three and a half and one gives it three. British Theatre Guide, London Theatre Reviews and JADAR publish no rating. Across the ten that score it, the average is 4.3 out of 5. The praise centres on the singing, above all Beverley Knight’s Emmeline, and on Kate Prince’s choreography. The doubts concern the writing and the venue: Theatre Weekly and JADAR find the score repetitive, and three critics say the hall’s sound loses lyrics.
What are critics saying about Sylvia?
The Spy in the Stalls
"entertaining, educational and moving in equal measure"
Reviewer: Katherine Gannon
Katherine Gannon calls the show empowering and notes that the audience applauded at key moments. She rates Naomi Katiyo at five-star level from her first scene and finds Beverley Knight just as strong.
"From the opening dance number, you want to follow these women into battle."
She also praises Kate Prince’s direction and choreography, the rap between Lloyd George and Churchill, and every department of the design.
Read Katherine Gannon’s full review at The Spy in the Stalls
A Young(ish) Perspective
The review argues that the hip-hop, funk and soul score does more than modernise the history: it gives the political arguments their momentum. It picks out Kenedy Small’s Jennie Churchill and Collette Guitart’s Clementine, and says the humour keeps the evening alive.
"These women were difficult because they had to be. This production lets them be difficult again."

The Theatre Flyer
Reviewer: Emma Knott
Emma Knott names the soundtrack as a highlight, likening it to a mix of Hamilton and Six, and says Katiyo more than holds her own beside Knight. She gives a special mention to Guitart’s One of the Doomed.
"Ultimately, Sylvia is a thrilling, uplifting and wonderfully fresh take on an important chapter of British history."
Her reservations are the size of the hall, which she thinks may cost the back rows some detail, and a pace that leaves little room for the emotional moments.
Theatre, Art and Film Reviews
"A fascinating history lesson wrapped in a spectacular theatrical experience"
Reviewer: Nina Gardner
Nina Gardner admires the choreography and a score that she says makes it almost impossible to sit still. She finds Katiyo terrific and picks out the confrontation between mother and daughter as a highlight.
"Beverley Knight is magnificent as Emmeline, bringing powerhouse vocals and real authority to the role."
She does find the later picture of Sylvia as almost saintly, with Emmeline increasingly the villain, a little one-sided, and the light tone uneasy beside the prison scenes.
Read Nina Gardner’s full review at Theatre, Art and Film Reviews

Musical Theatre Review
Reviewer: Lisa Martland
Lisa Martland says the close of Act I felt like a rally, which suits a hall that hosted suffragette meetings, and that Prince’s staging commands the space. She thinks the shift towards Sylvia in Act II leaves other characters behind and that the libretto could still be trimmed.
"It feels like a privilege to see Beverley Knight reprise her Olivier Award-winning role as Emmeline Pankhurst."
She adds that Katiyo goes up a notch once Sylvia breaks away from her family, and that the acoustics made some words hard to catch early on.
LondonTheatre1
Reviewer: Joseph Dunitz
Joseph Dunitz feels the story moves too quickly to land its emotional stakes, citing the death of Sylvia’s brother. For him the singing carries the evening.
"What is absolutely to love in this show is the sheer power of the cast’s vocals…"
He singles out Knight and Katiyo, Andrzej Goulding’s video work and Tony Gayle’s sound design.

London Box Office
Reviewer: Stuart King
Stuart King finds the book a little scattergun in what it takes from 25 years of history, but says the changes since 2018 favour entertainment over lecture. He praises the company numbers and Ivano Turco’s Silvio Corio.
"Beverley Knight is an extraordinary talent in any environment, but she fills the RAH auditorium with her star quality…"
1883 Magazine
"Votes for women come with a banging beat in Sylvia"
Reviewer: Nick Barr
Nick Barr took his 12-year-old daughter and enjoyed the evening from the first song, though he kept hearing Hamilton in it. He found Castell Parker’s Churchill too much of a panto villain and one love song wedged in.
"Katiyo has an incredible voice and the stage presence to match. She’s a hell of a rapper, too."
By the finale, he reports, his daughter was on her feet dancing.

LouReviews
Reviewer: Louise Penn
Louise Penn saw the work-in-progress run at the Old Vic in 2018 and finds the show much improved, with more focus on Sylvia herself. She praises the cast, but says the hall is a hard sell for a musical and the sound sometimes loses the lyrics.
"…her Sylvia is beautifully shaded as she searches for love, purpose, and connection."
She puts the show itself at about four stars and the overall experience nearer three, and settles on three and a half.
Theatre Weekly
"Prince’s expressive, story-driven choreography captures the physical and psychological weight of the uphill battle the suffragettes faced"
Reviewer: Stephen Gilchrist
Stephen Gilchrist separates the material from the staging. He thinks the show follows the Hamilton template without matching it, calls the lyrics lazy and the score repetitive, and finds most characters other than Knight’s Emmeline thin.
"The company dance their tootsies off to almost three hours of hip-hop, fun and soul."
The production itself he admires: the choreography, the stage pictures and the six-piece band under Sean Green.

British Theatre Guide
Reviewer: Sandra Giorgetti
Sandra Giorgetti says patchy sound in the huge auditorium buries many of the lyrics, but that the momentum holds. She feels the show raises Sylvia up at the expense of Emmeline’s reputation.
"…the bold physicality of the movement and the percussive score swell to fill the huge space…"
Read Sandra Giorgetti’s full review at British Theatre Guide
London Theatre Reviews
Reviewer: Anthea Arpad
Anthea Arpad calls Katiyo one to watch and says Prince’s direction and choreography scale up to the hall. She finds the songs too alike, misses a power ballad and thinks the black, white and beige design bleak.
"Knight owns the stage and fills the entire hall so effortlessly that she leaves the audience silenced…"

JADAR
JADAR’s critic is the least persuaded. The review finds the story jumpy, the rhymes forced and the choreography short of variety, and argues that a feminist musical spends too long on men and romance.
"The absolute lifeline of this production were the astonishing singers gracing the stage."
It praises Katiyo, Knight and Guitart, and suggests the show could work well for younger audiences.
For the production in pictures, see our Sylvia production photographs, and for the background to the run, our guide to everything you need to know about Sylvia at the Royal Albert Hall.
Sylvia is booking at the Royal Albert Hall until 15 November 2026.








