The reviews are in for Shakespeare’s Cousin, Jonathan Moore’s new play at the White Bear Theatre in Kennington, which puts the Jesuit poet Robert Southwell in a room with Elizabeth I’s chief priest-hunter, Sir Richard Topcliffe. The critics divide sharply over the writing. Some found it thoughtful and gripping; others sat through it as an overlong sermon. The acting is a different matter: Danny Solomon’s Southwell, Robin Kingsland’s Topcliffe and Alex Townson as the mysterious Sir Oliver are praised in almost every notice, including several that have little else good to say.
2.9 / 5 from 9 criticsThe verdict: nine reviews so far, all of them rated: two at four stars, one at three and a half, three at three and three at two, which averages 2.9 out of 5. The critics part company over Jonathan Moore’s script, which some find erudite and others find wordy and slow, especially in the second act. The cast of three is praised almost everywhere.
What are critics saying about Shakespeare’s Cousin?
Everything Theatre
"Set in Elizabethan England, this new play holds a mirror to current events"
Reviewer: Alice Grahame
Alice Grahame reads the play as a warning about surveillance and scapegoated minorities. She finds Moore’s modern English witty and easy to follow, although the debate about Shakespeare’s faith goes on too long and the epilogue feels cut off from everything before it.
"Kingsland is superb as Topcliffe, swinging rapidly between decent and depraved."
She warns that the violence makes it a hard watch, and thinks the play is substantial enough for a bigger stage.
London Pub Theatres
"Tudor religious divisions are still with us."
Reviewer: Francis Beckett
Francis Beckett was taught by Jesuits himself. He rejects the play’s view of the Reformation but admires it anyway, because it has a clear argument and makes it well.
"Shakespeare’s Cousin is one of the most thoughtful, interesting, gripping and erudite history plays I have seen."
He calls the first act a gripping two-hander between Solomon’s restrained Southwell and Kingsland’s complex Topcliffe. In his view the second act cools once the debates take over.
The Reviews Hub
"Interesting, intense, violent"
Reviewer: Patrick Shorrock
Patrick Shorrock sees three demanding parts, all well acted, in a play that gives the audience plenty to think about without telling it what to think. He adds that it raises more questions than it settles, which costs it some focus.
"…the confrontations between the players, especially the battle of wills between torturer and victim, make for a strongly dramatic evening."

ReviewsGate
"Flawed but stimulating and chills the blood."
Reviewer: William Russell
William Russell treats it as a work in progress. The interrogation scenes are well staged and well played, but the second encounter does not fit with the first, and a false ending set the audience applauding too early.
"…this is a fine instance of a fringe theatre providing a place for the play to be tried out."
He still thinks the play has a future, mainly because of the arguments between its three men.
A Young(ish) Perspective
"This new work explores the life of a lesser-known Elizabethan poet…"
"Danny Solomon brought Robert Southwell to life with poise and conviction"
The review likes all three performances but finds little tension in a script crowded with historical detail and explanation, and it doubts there is much evidence for a close bond between the two writers. It suggests the play needs another draft, while granting that it leaves you wanting to read Southwell’s poetry.
Fairy Powered Productions
"certainly worth seeing for the quality of the acting alone"
Reviewer: Mike Linane
Mike Linane calls it an actor’s showcase, with three strong parts that the cast make the most of, and he enjoys the turn the second act takes.
"…the dialogue is very dense and it demands total concentration from the audience the whole way through"
He warns that it is not an easy evening and may be too much for some.

LondonTheatre1
"One of those, mercifully very few, evenings in the theatre which seem much longer than they actually are!"
Reviewer: John Groves
John Groves praises the acting throughout, especially Kingsland’s understated Topcliffe, but finds the second act a long discussion in which almost nothing happens.
"The main problem with this play is that Moore always uses at least thirty words when one will suffice."
First Night Magazine
"Martyrical play is barely kept alive by botched execution"
Reviewer: Guillermo Nazara
Guillermo Nazara arrived hopeful and left disappointed. He calls the script pretentious and the structure confused, finds the characters barely change, and is the one critic here who rates the acting no higher than adequate.
"Danny Solomon gives the most competent performance as Southwell, playing the role with old-school flair and poise."
Pink Prince Theatre
"LOVE’S LABOUR’S DRAGGED OUT"
Reviewer: Neill Kovacic-Clarke
Neill Kovacic-Clarke likes the premise and admires how the torture is staged. He finds the script overwritten and the pace slow, though, with clunky scene changes and a false ending that drew applause too soon.
"The one thing that really kept me watching was the acting, because all three of them are genuinely brilliant."
Read Neill Kovacic-Clarke’s full review at Pink Prince Theatre
We covered the play’s announcement in September, with the background on Southwell and on Moore’s career: Shakespeare’s Cousin, a new play by Jonathan Moore, premieres at the White Bear Theatre. For more of this week’s notices, see our roundups of Cranford at the Orange Tree Theatre and Cloud 9 at the National Theatre.
Shakespeare’s Cousin is at the White Bear Theatre until 28 November 2026.
For more information, visit the official website.








