Skip to content

Review Roundup: JULIUS CAESAR at the Sam Wanamaker Playhouse

Adam Gillen as Mark Antony and Kate Duchêne as Julius Caesar in Julius Caesar at the Sam Wanamaker Playhouse, Shakespeare’s Globe. Photo by Marc Brenner

The reviews are in for Julius Caesar, the first staging of the play at Shakespeare’s Globe’s candlelit Sam Wanamaker Playhouse. Joe Hill-Gibbins has cut it to 90 minutes and four actors: Kate Duchêne as Caesar, Caoilfhionn Dunne as Brutus, Natey Jones as Cassius and Adam Gillen as Mark Antony, with two drummers above them. The critics agree that the room, the fire and the percussion make a tense, close-up evening. Where they part company is over what the cuts take away, and Gillen’s eccentric Antony draws the strongest reactions on both sides.

3.5 / 5 from 6 criticsThe verdict: six reviews so far, split down the middle. Time Out, The Reviews Hub and West End Best Friend give four stars, and The Standard, WhatsOnStage and BroadwayWorld give three, an average of 3.5 out of 5. Every critic admires the candlelight, the great metal disc and the drumming that barely stops. They divide over the cuts: half think the four-actor version sharpens the play, and half think it loses some of its weight. Most of them single out Adam Gillen’s Mark Antony, though The Standard is not convinced.

What are critics saying about Julius Caesar?

Time Out

"Joe Hill-Gibbins’ radically stripped back Julius Caesar is brilliantly inventive and murderously tense"

Reviewer: Tim Bano

Tim Bano is the most enthusiastic of the critics so far. He calls the production a four-person fight to the death, set to drumming that never lets up, and he has nothing but praise for the drastic cuts to a play of almost fifty characters.

"This is a brilliant act of butchery, leaving just the leanest, bloodiest, choicest cuts."

The high point for him is the funeral scene, where Adam Gillen’s Mark Antony plays the whole Roman mob himself. He finds the war and the ghosts that follow less gripping, but he blames the play for that, not the staging.

Read Tim Bano’s full review in Time Out

The Reviews Hub

"Atmospheric paired back Shakespeare."

Reviewer: John Cutler

John Cutler admits that some nuance goes missing in a 90-minute version for four performers, and decides that it does not matter much. He sees Rome turned into a grubby urban underworld where the conspirators look more like small-time criminals than statesmen.

"the piece works brilliantly as a gripping, darkly atmospheric rollercoaster ride into betrayal, rabble-rousing, and brutal comeuppance."

He is struck by Kate Duchêne playing the Soothsayer’s warning as Caesar’s own fit, and by Gillen getting the audience to join in the chant for Caesar’s will. He recommends it as a dark treat for the festive season.

Read John Cutler’s full review at The Reviews Hub

Natey Jones as Cassius and Caoilfhionn Dunne as Brutus in Julius Caesar at the Sam Wanamaker Playhouse, Shakespeare’s Globe. Photo by Marc Brenner

West End Best Friend

Reviewer: Sophie Luck

Sophie Luck credits Charles Balfour’s candlelight and the near-constant drumming with keeping her on the edge of her seat, and she likes the decision to make the audience the crowd that the senators address.

"This gripping and grounded production proves why there is no better place to watch the Bard's plays."

She singles out Caoilfhionn Dunne’s Brutus, caught between guilt and smugness. Her one reservation is the civil war, which she finds rushed, and she suggests the edit could have gone even further.

Read Sophie Luck’s full review at West End Best Friend

The Standard

"Succinct and punchy"

Reviewer: Martin Robinson

Martin Robinson enjoys Duchêne’s bombastic Caesar and Dunne’s brooding Brutus, who in his view steal the evening from Natey Jones’s Cassius and Gillen’s Antony. He is less sure about casting the audience as the Roman crowd, and he misses the smaller parts, especially the two wives.

"a masterpiece of editing and distillation, and a fresh take on a play that proves surprisingly malleable."

His verdict is a short, sharp version of the play that stops a little short of the whole thing.

Read Martin Robinson’s full review in The Standard

Natey Jones as Cassius and Caoilfhionn Dunne as Brutus share a candle in Julius Caesar at the Sam Wanamaker Playhouse. Photo by Marc Brenner

WhatsOnStage

"Joe Hill-Gibbins’ revival marks the first-ever staging of the tragedy in the indoor playhouse"

Reviewer: Lucinda Everett

Lucinda Everett thinks the play suits the cramped, candlelit room, and she rates the cast of four as excellent. She finds Gillen’s naive, sincere Antony and Dunne’s menacing Brutus bold choices, but she questions how well either fits the story the play tells.

"an early example of this production’s daring and riveting but sometimes ill-advised ideas."

She praises Rosanna Vize’s set and Balfour’s lighting, but she finds some of the more abstract moments in the gloom hard to follow.

Read Lucinda Everett’s full review at WhatsOnStage

Kate Duchêne as Julius Caesar in Julius Caesar at the Sam Wanamaker Playhouse, Shakespeare’s Globe. Photo by Marc Brenner

BroadwayWorld

"Joe Hill-Gibbins directs Shakespeare's great Roman play with just four actors"

Reviewer: Clementine Scott

Clementine Scott admires the atmosphere of dread that the candles, the giant silver disc and the percussion create.

"What this all means in practice is that this Julius Caesar never fails to hold the audience’s attention."

She still feels that substance is lost among the effects. The later scenes in Brutus and Cassius’s tent drag, and apart from Gillen’s unsettling Antony, the performances do not quite match the scale of the staging.

Read Clementine Scott’s full review at BroadwayWorld

For more on the production, see our guide to everything you need to know about Julius Caesar at the Sam Wanamaker Playhouse and our report on the four-strong company. For another very different take on the play this month, see our roundup of the RSC’s First Encounters: Julius Caesar.

Julius Caesar is booking at the Sam Wanamaker Playhouse until 14 February 2027.