Skip to content

Review Roundup: DESIRE UNDER THE ELMS at the Almeida Theatre

Kelly Gough and Zackary Momoh embrace in orange light in Desire Under the Elms at the Almeida Theatre. Photo by Marc Brenner

The reviews are in for Desire Under the Elms, Eugene O’Neill’s 1924 tragedy of land, lust and inheritance, at the Almeida Theatre. It is Rupert Goold’s last production as artistic director. Ebenezer Bamgboye moves the farm to the Deep South, adds a trio of musician-spirits and casts Zackary Momoh as Eben, Kelly Gough as his young stepmother Abbie and Antony Byrne as the tyrant Ephraim. The critics agree on Gough. They are far less united about Bamgboye’s heavily stylised staging, which some find gripping and others find suffocating.

3.1 / 5 from 10 criticsThe verdict: twelve reviews so far, and they are split. The Reviews Hub gives four and a half stars, The Guardian, BroadwayWorld and View from the Gods give four, WhatsOnStage and LondonTheatre.co.uk give three, and Liam O’Dell, London Box Office, All That Dazzles and The Stage give two. That makes an average of 3.1 out of 5 across the ten critics who give a rating. Everyone notices how heavily styled the production is, with its live music, ghosts and choreography. The disagreement is over whether that styling releases the play or smothers it. Almost all of them single out Kelly Gough’s Abbie, especially in the final act.

What are critics saying about Desire Under the Elms?

The Reviews Hub

"Aesthetically raw emotion"

Reviewer: A. Tran Ngoc

A. Tran Ngoc is the most enthusiastic critic so far. The review is captivated from the first eerie tableau, with Choolwe Laina Muntanga singing the audience down into a haunted New Orleans, and admires the softness Zackary Momoh finds inside Eben’s violence.

"the musical, physical and theatrical artistry is so vibrantly clear in this performance"

There are questions left hanging, chiefly how plausible it is for a Black son to inherit a Southern farm in that era, and why the live music drops away after the interval. But the craft, in this view, outweighs them.

Read A. Tran Ngoc’s full review at The Reviews Hub

The Guardian

"Kelly Gough is simply astounding as Desire Under the Elms reaches the heights of Greek tragedy"

Reviewer: Arifa Akbar

Arifa Akbar finds the first half over-styled, with director Ebenezer Bamgboye owing too much to Rebecca Frecknall’s way of working and the choreographed lovers giving off too little heat.

"her performance really does rise to the heights of Greek drama, intense and unstoppably tragic."

The second half is another matter. Once the actors are left simply to act, she says, the evening becomes powerful, and Kelly Gough as Abbie is off the scale. It is not perfect, she concludes, but it is a strong send-off for Rupert Goold’s final production as artistic director.

Read Arifa Akbar’s full review in The Guardian

Choolwe Laina Muntanga in Desire Under the Elms at the Almeida Theatre, with Nathaniel Wade and Tendai Humphrey Sitima behind her. Photo by Marc Brenner

BroadwayWorld

"This revival lives and breathes through the temperature of its performances"

Reviewer: Alexander Cohen

Alexander Cohen admits the expressionist approach is becoming a familiar house style, but he thinks it works here.

"It still injects O’Neill’s tightly wound poetry with a dizzying synthesis of hot-blooded intensity and balletic grace."

He enjoys Antony Byrne’s lecherous Ephraim and Gough’s feline Abbie. His one reservation is that the wandering ghosts and constant movement sometimes crowd out the drama, which he calls a minor quibble.

Read Alexander Cohen’s full review at BroadwayWorld

View from the Gods

Reviewer: Simon Jenner

Simon Jenner calls Bamgboye’s mix of O’Neill’s realism and his expressionist side an ingenious answer to a flawed but elemental play. He even credits the director with improving on O’Neill in the final scene.

"But particularly for Gough’s anguished, towering performance which deserves an award."

He admits the production’s reach may exceed its grasp, but he still calls it a must-see. He praises Momoh’s chemistry with Gough and Jack Knowles’ lighting.

Read Simon Jenner’s full review at View from the Gods

Jamie Beamish in Desire Under the Elms at the Almeida Theatre. Photo by Marc Brenner

WhatsOnStage

"Ebenezer Bamgboye’s revival of the Eugene O’Neill classic runs until 23 December"

Reviewer: Sarah Crompton

Sarah Crompton thinks the play itself is relentless and hard to stage, and she credits the casting of Momoh as Eben with raising its stakes. She calls him magnificent, and admires Rose Ryan’s choreography of the lovers.

"He throws everything at an expressionistic, visceral production that is always gripping"

Even so, she feels that neither the play nor the production quite reaches the depth of feeling it is straining for. She also notes that the setting leaves Byrne no room to soften Ephraim’s cruelty.

Read Sarah Crompton’s full review at WhatsOnStage

LondonTheatre.co.uk

"this bold Eugene O’Neill production is striking, visceral theatre"

Reviewer: Anya Ryan

Anya Ryan sees the production as a fitting farewell for Goold, but she warns that the constant music and stylised movement stretch the action and threaten to swamp the drama. In her view, some of the movement feels empty.

"But this is a daring directorial interpretation from Bamgboye, which makes for a striking and often visceral piece of theatre."

She notes how the cast carry the story on a largely bare stage, with Gough’s Abbie opening up as the affair grows.

Read Anya Ryan’s full review at LondonTheatre.co.uk

The company of Desire Under the Elms on stage at the Almeida Theatre under green light. Photo by Marc Brenner

London Box Office

Reviewer: Stuart King

Stuart King calls the play a tough watch, and finds the production uneven in texture.

"Ebenezer Bamgboye has made an omelet, but hasn’t necessarily cracked all the eggs to do so."

He respects the effort of reviving a rarely performed O’Neill, but finds that the updated version never builds enough momentum. He thinks the 2 hours 40 minutes outstays its welcome, and he calls it unlikely seasonal fare.

Read Stuart King’s full review at London Box Office

Liam O’Dell

"Tiring farm drama has a Frecknall familiarity"

Reviewer: Liam O’Dell

Liam O’Dell is the harshest of the critics. He cannot get past what he sees as borrowings from Frecknall, and he finds the trumpet, the shouting and the dance sequences get in the way of the play.

"It results in a stream of almost completely uninterrupted text devoid of dynamism"

He thinks the second act breathes more easily and gives Gough room for a raw, harrowing breakdown, but for him it comes too late to rescue the evening.

Read Liam O’Dell’s full review at Liam O’Dell

Tendai Humphrey Sitima playing guitar in Desire Under the Elms at the Almeida Theatre. Photo by Marc Brenner

All That Dazzles

"A striking take on Eugene O’Neill's story struggles to find its identity, instead lurking in the shadows of those that have come before"

Reviewer: Daz Gale

Daz Gale finds plenty of good ideas and big choices, and says the show is never boring. In his view, though, the ideas are realised unevenly and the production lives in the shadow of Rebecca Frecknall’s recent O’Neill revival at the same theatre.

"the result is a confused and underbaked production that wasn’t quite what I desired."

Read Daz Gale’s full review at All That Dazzles

British Theatre Guide

"Ebenezer Bamgboye’s revival of Eugene O’Neill’s Desire Under the Elms breathes new life into this American classic."

Reviewer: Rebecca Clifton

Rebecca Clifton, whose site gives no star ratings, likes the animal physicality Bamgboye draws from his cast and the brothers’ double act. She also enjoys the unexpected gentleness Byrne brings to Ephraim’s scenes with Abbie. She praises the acting, the lighting and the direction, but feels the play skirts its themes rather than committing to one.

"Unfortunately, I left quite indifferent, when I'd hoped to be mesmerised."

Read Rebecca Clifton’s full review at British Theatre Guide

Also reviewed by: The Stage (Dave Fargnoli, two stars, "Overshoots the mark") and The Telegraph ("Harrowing"), whose reviews sit behind paywalls.

Bamgboye’s previous production was Night City at Southwark Playhouse, and it also split the critics. For more from the Almeida this autumn, see our roundups of Triumph and Golden Boy, and our news on Dominic Cooke’s first season as Goold’s successor.

Desire Under the Elms runs at the Almeida Theatre until 23 December 2026.