Skip to content

Review Roundup: A HOMO ALONE 2: YIKES, WE DID IT AGAIN! at The Other Palace Studio

The cast of A Homo Alone 2: Yikes, We Did It Again! on a New York street at The Other Palace Studio. Photo by Danny Kaan The reviews are in for A Homo Alone 2: Yikes, We Did It Again!. Kevin McCallister is lost in New York again, and this time Jodie Prenger and Neil Hurst have made the trip strictly adults-only. The critics split on how much innuendo one evening can hold. They agree on the four-strong company. Jermaine Woods as a Rocky Horror-flavoured hotel manager, Jenny Bede as a Moira Rose-voiced mother and Charlotte Dixon as Marv and a Trump cameo get the warmest notices, alongside Thomas John Stocks as Kevin, under Laura Checkley's direction.

3.4 / 5 from 9 criticsThe verdict: ten reviews in. Four critics gave it four stars, four gave it three and one gave it two and a half, an average of 3.4 out of 5 across the nine ratings. The split is over the smut, which some found glorious and others found relentless. Nobody faults the cast, and Jermaine Woods, Jenny Bede and Charlotte Dixon are named again and again.

What are critics saying about A Homo Alone 2: Yikes, We Did It Again!?

Theatre Weekly

"a gift of a show for anyone who enjoys a bit of smut with their holiday cheer"

Reviewer: Greg Stewart

Greg Stewart had a rowdy night and says so. He credits the four-strong cast with carrying the evening through a string of punishing quick changes.

"The best parody comes from a show that loves what it’s sending up, and Prenger and Hurst clearly adore this franchise"

A couple of jokes drew groans rather than laughs, he admits, but the gags arrive so fast that a miss is soon forgotten.

Read Greg Stewart’s full review at Theatre Weekly

The Spy in the Stalls

"they’ve managed to kick off the festive season with a cracker"

Reviewer: Jonathan Evans

Jonathan Evans came to the sequel without having seen the first instalment. It did not matter at all.

"It takes dedication, hard work and talent to be a good actor; but it takes a particular skill to be silly."

He finds the jokes predictable, telegraphed a mile off, but calls the production slick and singles out Jenny Bede as Kevin’s mother and Charlotte Dixon’s Trump.

Read Jonathan Evans’s full review at The Spy in the Stalls

Kevin caught between the two burglars beneath a Broadway street sign in A Homo Alone 2: Yikes, We Did It Again! at The Other Palace Studio. Photo by Danny Kaan

The Recs

"Everything goes for the New York gays – especially when you’re ho hoe home alone!"

Reviewer: Erik Gunther

Erik Gunther praises a quartet that covers ten characters between them, with strong vocals from Jermaine Woods and Jenny Bede.

"What truly steals the show is Kevin’s mum’s identity crisis, hilariously channelled through Catherine O’Hara’s Moira Rose."

His reservation is Kevin himself: the script gives the lead too few good jokes and leans on familiar gay stereotypes at times.

Read Erik Gunther’s full review at The Recs

Theatre and Tonic

Reviewer: George

George calls it the perfect Christmas night out and keeps the biggest praise for Jermaine Woods, who moves from Kevin’s closeted dad to Harry to a full Rocky Horror turn.

"Each time Woods came on stage I couldn’t wait to see what happened next and his comedic timing landed every joke."

The audience participation, from the front-row bag pass to pigeons thrown at the burglars, is a large part of the fun.

Read George’s full review at Theatre and Tonic

Jenny Bede in A Homo Alone 2: Yikes, We Did It Again! at The Other Palace Studio. Photo by Danny Kaan

WhatsOnStage

Reviewer: Sonny Waheed

Sonny Waheed thinks this is a show that needed someone to say less is more. The crude material is relentless, he argues, and it buries the jokes that genuinely work.

"Thankfully, the show has two secret weapons in Charlotte Dixon and Jermaine Woods."

Dixon and Woods as the two burglars are the evening’s high point for him. He would have liked far more light and shade.

Read Sonny Waheed’s full review at WhatsOnStage

West End Best Friend

Reviewer: Heidi Downing

Heidi Downing enjoys the casting, the cameos and the X-rated Broadway billboards dotted around the set.

"Jermaine Woods’ Tim Curry is one of the greatest highlights of this production."

The staging is her complaint. Much of it plays end-on in a two-sided studio, and the balcony scenes run long for anyone whose sightlines miss them.

Read Heidi Downing’s full review at West End Best Friend

The company strike the famous hands-to-face scream in A Homo Alone 2: Yikes, We Did It Again! at The Other Palace Studio. Photo by Danny Kaan

Operation Live Theatre

Reviewer: Xi Ye

Xi Ye finds the first act thoroughly entertaining and the second more repetitive, as the writing starts to run thin.

"While it isn’t the funniest Homo in town, it is certainly the raciest."

The cast make up for it, with Jenny Bede’s crowd work and the rewritten Christmas songs the highlights of the night.

Read Xi Ye’s full review at Operation Live Theatre

The Reviews Hub

"Kinky Christmas Parody"

Reviewer: Rebecca Clifton

Rebecca Clifton is the coolest of the critics so far. She enjoys the parody songs but wanted direction that went much further over the top.

"Though there is naughtiness, it never quite tips into unabashed scandal. A Homo Alone 2 feels too pared back."

Charlotte Dixon is the performer she cannot take her eyes off. The crowd work and Jenny Bede’s accents leave her unconvinced.

Read Rebecca Clifton’s full review at The Reviews Hub

Kevin studies a map of New York as the burglars creep up behind him in A Homo Alone 2: Yikes, We Did It Again! at The Other Palace Studio. Photo by Danny Kaan

All That Dazzles

Reviewer: Daz Gale

Daz Gale finds the writing underbaked, as if the show were still a draft, with too many easy jokes.

"A Homo Alone 2 may be basic, but boy is it fun."

Jenny Bede is the undoubted star for him, and Jermaine Woods brings the house down with a new take on Sweet Transvestite.

Read Daz Gale’s full review at All That Dazzles

Also reviewed by: The Stage (Paul Vale, three stars, "Full-throttle parody").

For more on the production, see everything you need to know about A Homo Alone 2, our first look at the production photos and our report on Kevin heading for New York.

A Homo Alone 2: Yikes, We Did It Again! is booking at The Other Palace Studio until 3 January 2027.