Skip to content

Review Roundup: FLORENCE at Park Theatre

Honor Santa Barnes in Florence at Park Theatre. Photo by Matt Hunter The notices are in for Florence, Honor Santa Barnes's one-woman satire of the London art world, which has arrived in Park90 at the Park Theatre after outings at The Other Palace and the Edinburgh Fringe. Barnes plays an Irish art-history graduate who, rejected by gallery after gallery, invents a cut-glass alter ego and talks her way into a job selling pictures to the rich. On one point the critics agree completely: Barnes herself, whose accents and quick-change characters win praise from every quarter. Where they part company is the play. Half of them find a sharp, unsettling study of identity; the other half want a darker, riskier schemer at its centre, or a story that slows down long enough to land its turns.

3.6 / 5 from 8 criticsThe verdict: eight reviews so far, and every one of them carries a rating: four four-star notices, two at three and a half and two at three, an average of 3.6 out of 5. Nobody has a bad word for Honor Santa Barnes as a performer. The split is over her script, which the four-star camp calls sharp and disciplined, and which the more guarded critics find too easy on its heroine and in too much of a hurry.

What are critics saying about Florence?

BroadwayWorld

"An exciting one-woman-play explores what it takes to break it into the dark world of art."

Reviewer: Cindy Marcolina

Cindy Marcolina calls the piece a biting, dark satire and an excellent calling card for its writer-performer.

"Barnes slips in and out of a variety of accents with seamless flair."

She singles out the mid-show twist, which recasts everything that went before and pushes the play somewhere more disturbing, and she credits El Blackwood's precise direction. Her closing line is that she cannot wait to see what Barnes does next.

Read Cindy Marcolina’s full review at BroadwayWorld

Theatre Weekly

"It’s a masterclass in economical and punchy storytelling"

Reviewer: George Rennie

George Rennie places the play somewhere between The Talented Mr. Ripley and Inventing Anna, and admires how vividly it draws London's moneyed art scene.

"Her accent work in particular is an impressive feat and it’s clear this is someone to watch."

He notes that it is not always clear whom the narrator is addressing, and that the ending leaves questions open, but he counts both in the show's favour. For him it is bold, funny and compelling.

Read George Rennie’s full review at Theatre Weekly

Honor Santa Barnes performing Florence in Park90 at Park Theatre. Photo by Matt Hunter

West End Best Friend

Reviewer: Brian Penn

Brian Penn reads the play as a study of what happens when faking it to make it takes over a life, and finds it more complex than its premise suggests.

"Honor Santa Barnes delivers a remarkable performance full of attitude and energy."

He praises the half-dozen characters and the near-perfect regional accents, and argues that the play's real achievement is making a deceitful heroine sympathetic. He ends by calling it a towering piece of work from its writer and performer.

Read Brian Penn’s full review at West End Best Friend

All That Dazzles

Reviewer: Cat Wiltshire

Cat Wiltshire thinks the writing is the production's greatest strength, combining social satire about class and access with an increasingly unsettling look at identity.

"As a performer, Honor Santa Barnes is an impressive and captivating presence."

She does find the pace so quick that some ideas need more room, and the darker turns occasionally rushed. Even so, she calls the show entertaining, intelligent and thought-provoking.

Read Cat Wiltshire’s full review at All That Dazzles

Honor Santa Barnes in Florence, Park Theatre. Photo by Matt Hunter

London Unattached

"Honor Santa Barnes’ artful one-woman tragicomedy back for a short run"

Reviewer: Sarah Trivuncic

Sarah Trivuncic expected a glamorous tale of art-world fraud and found something lighter, closer to Fleabag than to Prima Facie.

"The pace is quick, Santa Barnes is endearing and at times relatable."

She feels Florence herself stays something of a blank, lacking Tom Ripley's menace, and thinks the show is most interesting when its heroine goes home to Ireland. She would happily see more of the supporting characters Barnes sketches.

Read Sarah Trivuncic’s full review at London Unattached

LouReviews

Reviewer: Louise Penn

Louise Penn sees a pointed comment on the masks people wear in public, and enjoys its black humour and its gallery of quickly sketched characters.

"It is funny, disarming, and occasionally disturbing, and is certainly helped by Honor’s personable performance…"

She was less convinced by how easily the heroine rises, and by the unclear question of whom she is telling the story to. At 55 minutes, she says, it still leaves you thinking.

Read Louise Penn’s full review at LouReviews

Honor Santa Barnes lights a match in Florence at Park Theatre. Photo by Matt Hunter

London Box Office

Reviewer: Stuart King

Stuart King sees the evening chiefly as a showcase for Barnes's mimicry, delivered at a breakneck pace, and he thinks she seizes the chance with gusto.

"Minor gripes aside Ms HSB has the chutzpah to deliver a yarn with confidence"

He finds some art-world details unconvincing, from a Picasso's price tag to the pronunciation of St Moritz, and thinks the material would benefit from a slower, clearer arc.

Read Stuart King’s full review at London Box Office

The Reviews Hub

"Ripleyesque art drama"

Reviewer: John Cutler

John Cutler calls the single-hander serviceable, and enjoys its mocking portrait of the gallery world and Barnes's nimble switches between accents.

"Florence really ought to be a far more cunning, high-stakes schemer than she actually is."

His reservation is that the play makes her rise too easy, so the audience's sympathy is never really tested. He left feeling a little short-changed.

Read John Cutler’s full review at The Reviews Hub

We covered the transfer when it was announced: see Florence transfers to Park Theatre this November for the background to the run.

Florence plays in Park90 at the Park Theatre until 21 November.