The reviews are in for Donald, Stefano Massini’s play about the making of Donald Trump, which is receiving its UK premiere at the Ustinov Studio, Theatre Royal Bath, in a version adapted and directed by Sean Foley. As in Massini’s The Lehman Trilogy, three actors carry the whole story: Elliot Cowan plays Trump from his childhood in Queens to the top of Trump Tower, while Oscar Batterham and Jo Herbert play everyone he meets on the way. The critics are agreed on the craft. Cowan’s impersonation is praised in every notice, Batterham and Herbert are admired for their quick-change versatility, and Akhila Krishnan’s video design is singled out again and again. Where they part company is over the play itself: BroadwayWorld, The Reviews Hub and The Guardian find a funny and revealing portrait, while WhatsOnStage, All That Dazzles and The Independent find that it never gets beneath the caricature and stops well short of the presidency, and The Stage calls it disappointing.
3.3 / 5 from 8 criticsThe verdict: eleven reviews in so far. BroadwayWorld gives Donald five stars and The Reviews Hub four and a half; The Guardian gives it four; The Independent, StageTalk and The Stage give it three; WhatsOnStage and All That Dazzles give it two. Across the eight star ratings the average is 3.3 out of 5. Almost every notice praises Elliot Cowan’s Trump and the quick-change work of Oscar Batterham and Jo Herbert; the division is over whether Stefano Massini’s script ever finds the man behind the performance.
What are critics saying about Donald?
BroadwayWorld
"New entertaining portrayal of Donald Trump's rise to the top"
Reviewer: Cheryl Markosky
The warmest notice so far. Cheryl Markosky judges the timing of the staging, just after the midterms, to be ideal, and calls the evening storytelling at its best.
"Elliot Cowan's tremendous as Trump, perfectly capturing his pouting, gurning and eyebrow-raising facial expressions"
She gives equal credit to Herbert and Batterham for the speed of their changes between roles, to Alice Power’s design, and to the wardrobe and wig teams, and rates the multimedia staging the slickest of the year.
The Reviews Hub
"Bold. Brazen. Brilliant"
Reviewer: Chris Harris
Chris Harris warns that this is a loud and unsubtle telling of the Trump story, and argues that the noise suits its subject. He finds Cowan convincing in both look and voice, and notes that the short scenes leave the supporting characters lightly drawn.
"Overall, whatever you think of the man himself, this is a show that will live long in the memory"
His highlight is the three-screen set and video design, and he expects the production to follow earlier Ustinov shows into the West End.

The Guardian
"Is Donald Trump beyond caricature? Not at all – here’s his hilarious origin story"
Reviewer: Mark Lawson
Mark Lawson sets the play beside Mike Bartlett’s The 47th and the film The Apprentice, and finds it closer to the latter in concentrating on the years that formed Trump’s habits.
"Elliot Cowan’s scarily convincing Trump captures the mouth pouts, chin juts, sculpting hands and sudden stretched or staccato intonations."
He picks out Batterham’s Roy Cohn and Herbert as Trump’s mother, admires the speed of Foley’s staging and Krishnan’s video, and concludes that the evening avoids easy satire in favour of a funny and serious account of how Trump came to be.
The Independent
"A terrific impersonation and some hard-working wigs – but Trump is an impossible theatrical subject"
Reviewer: Georgina Brown
Georgina Brown enjoys Cowan’s Trump and much of the comedy that comes with it.
"As impersonations go, Elliot Cowan’s is terrific, fluent and fluid – and often very funny."
She is less taken with the play, which she finds episodic and closer to a one-man show than a drama, ending before Trump turned to politics. The video projections and Helen Keane’s wigs are, for her, the most memorable things in it.

StageTalk
Reviewer: Mike Whitton
Mike Whitton admires the pace, the video design and Beth Duke’s sound, and describes a first half played as broad sketch comedy before the tone darkens after the interval with the arrival of Roy Cohn.
"Technically very impressive indeed, and extremely well-acted, Donald has many strengths. However, it is tonally uncertain…"
His regret is that the glimpses of vulnerability the play offers are raised and then left undeveloped.
WhatsOnStage
Reviewer: Kris Hallett
Kris Hallett finds the laughter frequent and Cowan’s impersonation impressive, and praises Batterham, Herbert, the wigs and Alice Power’s three video walls. His objection is to the play, which in his view never finds a shape, leaves out the presidency and reads like a chapter torn from a longer book.
"As two hours of theatrical impersonation, it is frequently entertaining. As drama, however, it feels oddly insubstantial."

All That Dazzles
Reviewer: Seth Wilby
Seth Wilby finds the backstory genuinely interesting, the impersonation hilarious and the video design extraordinary, and thinks Batterham’s Roy Cohn the most intriguing figure on stage. But he argues that the script never looks beneath the surface and that the play is unsure of its purpose.
"It’s a play that can be admired for the effort, but shouldn’t yet have left the boardroom."
The Bath and Wiltshire Parent
"a big performance of an even bigger ego"
Reviewer: Ian Waller
Ian Waller calls the production inventive, loud and often hilarious, and marvels at the speed of the costume changes in so small a space. His one reservation is that the script gives Trump a voice more articulate and reflective than the man himself.
"Still, despite these reservations, Donald is an exceptionally clever and entertaining production, with three outstanding performances"
Read Ian Waller’s full review at The Bath and Wiltshire Parent

The Fine Times Recorder
Reviewer: GP-W
The Fine Times Recorder admires the set, the quick changes of Batterham and Herbert, and Batterham’s Cohn in particular. It finds the production too noisy, visually and aurally, thinks Cowan moves too much, and suspects that fear of legal action has held Massini back from the sharper play the material allows.
"I’m sure this play has legs, but there’s a lot of work to be done."
Also reviewed by: The Stage (Rosemary Waugh, three stars, "Leaves you craving more") and The Times (Dominic Maxwell, "amazingly, this Trump comedy has new things to say").
For more critics’ verdicts, see our roundups of The Sea at Theatre Royal Bath and Julius Caesar at the Sam Wanamaker Playhouse.
Donald plays at the Ustinov Studio, Theatre Royal Bath until Saturday 5 December.
For more information, visit the official website.








