Skip to content

Review Roundup: THE UGLY ONE at the Arcola Theatre

German Segal and Anastasia Velique in The Ugly One at the Arcola Theatre. Photo by Alina Saffron The reviews are in for The Ugly One, Marius von Mayenburg's satire on beauty and identity, which Broken Nose Theatre has revived at the Arcola Theatre in Maja Zade's translation. Ramin Gray directs it again nearly twenty years after he staged the play's UK premiere at the Royal Court, with German Segal as Lette, an engineer who learns that everyone around him finds his face unbearably ugly and has it remade by a surgeon. Four of the five critics found the play's jokes about cosmetic surgery sharper now than when it was written, and the cast of four, switching between characters without a change of costume, drew warm notices. The division is over the staging: three reviewers found it quick and inventive, while The Stage and A Young(ish) Perspective thought it too cool and restrained for the farce in the writing.

3.7 / 5 from 5 criticsThe verdict: five reviews so far, every one of them rated: three four-star notices, one at three and a half stars and one at three, an average of 3.7 out of 5. Four of the five find the play's satire on cosmetic surgery and self-image more pointed today than when it was written. What divides them is Ramin Gray's bare, fast-changing staging, which the warmer reviews credit with releasing the comedy and the cooler ones blame for keeping it at a distance.

What are critics saying about The Ugly One?

Everything Theatre

"A thought-provoking play that considers identity with creative flair and ingenuity."

Reviewer: Paul Hegarty

"Broken Nose Theatre are currently presenting a splendid revival of The Ugly One at Arcola Theatre, and it is well worth catching."

Paul Hegarty recommends the revival and finds that the play has something sharp to say about how looks govern careers and marriages. He singles out German Segal's puzzled, evidence-gathering Lette and enjoys the ensemble conjuring the operation through sound effects alone, and he gives Gray credit for making a talkative script and a sparse stage work.

Read Paul Hegarty’s full review at Everything Theatre

The Spy in the Stalls

"This play’s commentary feels more relevant now than ever."

Reviewer: Blake Booth

"The cast of four took on seven characters with ease, and kept the audience laughing throughout their performance."

Blake Booth calls the script witty and quick, and admires the way Gray trusts the audience to keep up with actors who change character without any change of costume or voice, although the switches that happen mid-sentence sometimes took a moment to register. Charlie Balfour's lighting and Jeremy Herbert's chair-lined set are praised for keeping the evening playful.

Read Blake Booth’s full review at The Spy in the Stalls

Michael Tcherepashenets (right) in The Ugly One at the Arcola Theatre. Photo by Alina Saffron

Theatre and Tonic

Reviewer: Greta

"Satire is a very prominent element of this production, whose dark humour never falters"

Greta reads the play as a comment on the way social media picks over strangers' faces, and describes an hour of theatre that feels strange and distinctly European. She puts some unevenness down to first-night nerves and warns that the brightly lit, stripped-back staging demands close attention to fast dialogue, but she promises an enjoyable evening to anyone prepared to give it.

Read Greta’s full review at Theatre and Tonic

A Young(ish) Perspective

"A thought-provoking exploration of beauty, identity and power."

"Slow and stripped back, the staging lacks the pace and escalating absurdity necessary to propel Lette’s descent into chaos."

This review admires the acting, praising Segal's shift from innocence to menace, Anastasia Velique's deadpan timing as Lette's wife and Michael Tcherepashenets's unsettling surgeon. Its reservation is the production, which it felt never commits to the farce in the writing and could have tied the story more closely to the present day.

Read the full review at A Young(ish) Perspective

Anastasia Velique in The Ugly One at the Arcola Theatre. Photo by Alina Saffron

Also reviewed by: The Stage (Dave Fargnoli, three stars, "Cruel, acrid humour").

This has been a busy week of openings on the London fringe. Read what the critics made of Florence at Park Theatre and Relative Motion at Southwark Playhouse Borough, and we will update this page as further reviews of The Ugly One appear.

The Ugly One runs at the Arcola Theatre until 19 December 2026.

For more information, visit the official website.