
4.6 / 5 from 5 criticsThe verdict: five reviews in so far, and every one of them rated. BroadwayWorld, Everything Theatre and Theatre and Tonic gave it five stars; LondonTheatre1 and North West End UK gave it four. That makes an average of 4.6 out of 5. The ensemble is the common thread: all five critics praise the acting.
What are critics saying about Round Lights?
BroadwayWorld
"Marvellous new play in which the ensemble cast shines"
Reviewer: Gary Naylor
Gary Naylor admits a play about wartime UFO sightings sounded unpromising on paper. The production changed his mind. He credits the writing for keeping the story clear of conspiracy hokum, and the cast for making the squadron feel real.
"…a continual source of unexpected delights as the plot twists and turns, quite the beacon in fringe theatre…"
His only complaint is that he wanted more time with these men. He says he would welcome a sequel.
Everything Theatre
"Unmissable!"
Reviewer: Philip Rham
Philip Rham found the play intriguing and funny in equal parts, and enjoyed the homely detail Edgar threads through life on the base. He saves his warmest words for the acting.
"The five actors, directed flawlessly by Edgar, are all superb to a man."
He also praises the accents, the Cornish one in particular, and the closing coup that leaves the audience to decide what was really up there.

Theatre and Tonic
Reviewer: Penny Walshe
Penny Walshe was struck by what the play has to say about language, spin and what a journalist is allowed to print. She calls the cast a real team effort and picks out Tom Canavan as the standout.
"It has humour, mystery, tragedy and recounts extraordinary events with empathy and credibility."
She thinks there is enough material for a longer evening with an interval, so the flash-forward scenes could land harder.
LondonTheatre1
Reviewer: Chris Omaweng
Chris Omaweng liked that the play skips the conspiracy theories and lets its airmen simply admit they do not know what they saw. He found it perceptive about war without tipping into sentimentality.
"Thoughtful and witty in equal measure, the ninety-five-minute running time felt considerably less than that."
Unusually for him, he would have welcomed more of the time-hopping post-war subplots.

North West End UK
Reviewer: Paul Ackroyd
Paul Ackroyd calls the acting excellent, though he finds the American pilots a touch broader than the rest. Josh Penrose’s Cornish technician supplies much of the humour.
"Canavan, as the English journalist, is thoroughly naturalistic and believable from the very moment he enters the auditorium"
He notes that the play never settles whether the airmen’s stories are true, and that the lighting effects add to the mystery.
More first-night verdicts from Brockley on the Best of Theatre blog: our roundups of Crime and Punishment and Flock at the Jack Studio Theatre.
Round Lights runs at the Jack Studio Theatre, 410 Brockley Road, London SE4, until Saturday 28 November 2026.
For more information, visit the official website.









