Skip to content

Review Roundup: INTO THE WOODS at the Noël Coward Theatre

Simbi Akande, Laura Pitt-Pulford, John Dagleish, Gracie McGonigal and Keith Ramsay in Into the Woods. Photo by Johan PerssonThe reviews are in for Into the Woods, which had its official West End opening at the Noël Coward Theatre on Wednesday 7 October after an Olivier-winning run at the Bridge. Stephen Sondheim and James Lapine’s fairytale musical sends a Baker and his Wife into the forest to lift a curse, then asks what comes after happily ever after. The welcome is warm almost everywhere: Jordan Fein’s production is judged to have travelled with its magic intact, Kate Fleetwood’s returning Witch draws the strongest praise, and the new Baker and Wife, John Dagleish and Laura Pitt-Pulford, are close behind. Where the critics part company is over the length, which a minority feel by the end of the evening.

4.6 / 5 from 21 criticsThe verdict: twenty-five reviews in for the West End transfer: twelve five-star notices, nine four-star, three outlets that publish no rating and The Times behind its paywall. Among those that score it, the average is 4.6 out of 5, and almost every critic singles out Kate Fleetwood’s Witch.

What are critics saying about INTO THE WOODS?

WhatsOnStage

Reviewer: Alex Wood

Alex Wood finds that the move from the Bridge into a proscenium house makes Jordan Fein’s staging feel plusher and more intimate, and that the returning cast members have only deepened their work.

"one of the best single performances on any West End stage right now"

That accolade goes to Kate Fleetwood’s Witch, which he finds more playful and more truthful than at the Bridge. He also enjoys the newcomers, John Dagleish and Laura Pitt-Pulford as the Baker and his Wife above all, and credits the sound and video design with making the giant’s arrival rattle the building.

Read Alex Wood’s full review at WhatsOnStage

London Theatre

"this sublime Olivier-winning revival is utterly magical"

Reviewer: Julia Rank

Julia Rank says the production has crossed the river without losing any of its magic, and that the new members of the company add to it.

"This return to the woods is not to be missed."

She singles out the lived-in chemistry between Dagleish and Pitt-Pulford, the dry humour and sheer power of Fleetwood’s Witch, and the way Tom Scutt’s set and Aideen Malone’s lighting turn the forest into a living space.

Read Julia Rank’s full review at London Theatre

Theatre Weekly

"an outstanding revival of a musical masterpiece"

Reviewer: Greg Stewart

Greg Stewart notes that this is the musical’s first West End staging in three decades, and argues that Fein strikes the difficult balance between its comedy and its darkness.

"Kate Fleetwood’s Witch is simply unforgettable."

He calls the Baker and his Wife the emotional core of the evening, finds the princes’ scenes riotously funny, and thinks Scutt’s design has transferred beautifully to its new home.

Read Greg Stewart’s full review at Theatre Weekly

Simbi Akande, Laura Pitt-Pulford, John Dagleish and Keith Ramsay in Into the Woods. Photo by Johan Persson

Theatre and Tonic

Reviewer: Penny

Penny reports that the production has lost none of its impact in the change of venue, and gives particular credit to Fein for making a knotty piece accessible, moving and very funny.

"It’s theatre at its absolute finest."

She welcomes back Gracie McGonigal and Fleetwood, praises the new Cinderella and Baker’s Wife, and tells readers who saw it at the Bridge to book again.

Read Penny’s full review at Theatre and Tonic

BroadwayWorld

Reviewer: Cheryl Markosky

Markosky is captivated by Tom Scutt’s woodland and costumes, and ranks Aideen Malone’s lighting above any other in memory.

"Scutt's glorious, wooded set on a traditional proscenium-arched stage resembles a child's innocent toy theatre."

Kate Fleetwood’s Witch, especially in ‘Stay With Me’, John Dagleish and Laura Pitt-Pulford’s Baker and Wife, and the preening princes of ‘Agony’ all earn praise, and the jewel-box Noël Coward is judged a good fit for the piece.

Read Cheryl Markosky’s full review at BroadwayWorld

The Reviews Hub

"A path worth taking"

Reviewer: Maryam Philpott

Philpott finds the transfer funnier and more claustrophobic in its smaller home, calls the cast uniformly excellent, and thinks Kate Fleetwood’s returning Witch is more commanding than ever.

"…a glorious, funny, moving and timeless production that relishes its smaller space at the Noël Coward Theatre…"

The two self-regarding princes are a comic highlight, the forest has been cleverly compressed to suggest depth on a narrower stage, and the second act’s bigger questions about responsibility and love land with full force.

Read Maryam Philpott’s full review at The Reviews Hub

West End Best Friend

Reviewer: Chris Abbott

Abbott thinks the move from the Bridge’s open stage to a proscenium arch has sharpened the production, and credits the new Baker and Wife, John Dagleish and Laura Pitt-Pulford, with real truth and feeling, Pitt-Pulford’s voice above all.

"…has resulted in a tighter, funnier and ultimately even more satisfying production of Into the Woods."

Michael S. Siegel’s Narrator, Gracie McGonigal’s scheming Little Red and Kate Fleetwood’s ‘Last Midnight’ are singled out, while the new princes are judged very good, if not yet the equal of their predecessors.

Read Chris Abbott’s full review at West End Best Friend

A scene from Into the Woods at the Noël Coward Theatre. Photo by Johan Persson

Musical Theatre Review

Reviewer: Lee Mottershead

Mottershead says the revival has lost none of its power or fun on the trip from the Bridge, and relishes a Witch from Kate Fleetwood who is grotesque and gloriously camp at once.

"…here is a production that truly does justice to Sondheim’s exquisite music and lyrics."

Tom Scutt’s design and Jordan Fein’s direction are both praised, along with Matthew Seadon-Young and Lucas Koch’s ‘Agony’, Gracie McGonigal’s greedy Little Red and Keith Ramsay’s Jack.

Read Lee Mottershead’s full review at Musical Theatre Review

All That Dazzles

Reviewer: Seth Wilby

Wilby credits Jordan Fein with a restrained, meticulously controlled staging that trusts the material, adores the Milky White puppet, and welcomes the small textual changes, including a larger part for Rapunzel.

"…like a master puppeteer invisibly pulling the strings of this intensely poignant and seamlessly funny production."

The one qualification is the set: in a proscenium house Tom Scutt’s forest feels more boxed in than it did at the Bridge, which makes the first act a little less immersive, although the confinement suits the darker second.

Read Seth Wilby’s full review at All That Dazzles

The Spy in the Stalls

"Compelling and captivating"

Reviewer: Jonathan Evans

Evans finds the comedy brought to the fore without any loss of darkness, and calls the cast impeccable across the board, from John Dagleish and Laura Pitt-Pulford’s cosy chemistry to Gracie McGonigal’s mischievous Little Red.

"This is an astonishing piece of theatre that highlights every note, cadence and inflection of Sondheim’s extraordinary score."

Kate Fleetwood is the standout, her ‘Last Midnight’ lifted by Aideen Malone’s lighting, and the closing advice is that audiences will not want to leave the woods.

Read Jonathan Evans’s full review at The Spy in the Stalls

Love London Love Culture

The unsigned review, by a writer seeing the musical on stage for the first time, enjoys the production’s mix of darkness and glee and the respect it shows the score, with ‘No One Is Alone’ and ‘Children Will Listen’ landing hardest.

"…it is hard to imagine that any other staging has been quite as brilliant as Jordan Fein’s production."

Tom Scutt’s intimate set and Aideen Malone’s lighting are praised, as are Kate Fleetwood’s mischievous Witch, the Pitt-Pulford and Dagleish partnership and the princes’ ‘Agony’. The site scores in hearts rather than stars, and gives it the full five.

Read the full review at Love London Love Culture

The company of Into the Woods. Photo by Johan Persson

Time Out

"Jordan Fein’s Olivier-winning Sondheim revival makes the leap to the West End with all of its magic intact"

Time Out’s critic thinks the mostly new cast keeps the show every bit as good as it was south of the river, with Fleetwood owning the stage and the Baker and his Wife a lovely vocal match.

"It’s a wordy, fiddly, nearly three-hour musical about fairytales, and somehow it flies by."

The review picks out the princes’ “Agony” as the funniest number of the night, and the way the company slips in and out of the trees as what sets the staging apart.

Read the full review at Time Out

The Arts Desk

"honouring a masterpiece"

Reviewer: David Nice

David Nice regards the piece itself as close to perfect, and is satisfied that this staging serves it, with no complaint about the many cast changes.

"Dagleish is also the best Baker I’ve seen"

He admires Simbi Akande’s truthful Cinderella and the two princes, and his one real reservation is heavy amplification that sometimes blurs the words.

Read David Nice’s full review at The Arts Desk

LondonTheatre1

Reviewer: Chris Omaweng

Chris Omaweng is the most measured voice here. He found it a long evening, felt the second act turned preachy towards the end, and was not won over by the puppet cow or the beanstalk.

"a very satisfying and gritty show, with touches of lighthearted silliness…"

He values the production for playing the material straight rather than reaching for a novel angle, and for what it shows about the power of storytelling.

Read Chris Omaweng’s full review at LondonTheatre1

Jonathan Baz Reviews

Reviewer: Emma Kaabachi

Emma Kaabachi thinks the visuals are flawless, with Scutt’s looming trees and Malone’s lighting making a landscape that seems alive.

"the overall aesthetic is so refined that this production could almost be frozen in time"

She praises Fleetwood’s authority and calls McGonigal’s Red Ridinghood fearless, but finds the near three-hour running time hard to sustain in the first act, and the repeated end-of-scene poses less striking each time.

Read Emma Kaabachi’s full review at Jonathan Baz Reviews

A scene from Into the Woods at the Noël Coward Theatre. Photo by Johan Persson

The Recs

Reviewer: Erin Muldoon

Muldoon thinks the design is the production’s greatest strength, credits Jordan Fein’s use of space with making the audience feel like intruders on the story, and picks out Gracie McGonigal’s bold, funny Little Red as the standout turn.

"…the most striking assets to Into The Woods are Tom Scutt’s set and Aideen Malone’s lighting."

The reservations are the overlapping speech-singing in the company numbers, which can make the plot hard to follow, and a running time of two hours 45 minutes over which the recurring melodies start to feel retold.

Read Erin Muldoon’s full review at The Recs

Plays International

Reviewer: David Wootton

Wootton is taken with the full-grown naturalism of Tom Scutt’s forest under Aideen Malone’s shifting light, a reveal all the more striking for the bare stage that precedes it, and with the comedy of Agony, which Matthew Seadon-Young and Lucas Koch almost steal the show with.

"Together they confirm him as one of the most substantial talents in theatre today…"

That verdict is on Jordan Fein, weighed alongside his Broken Glass at the Young Vic. He has Fleetwood anchoring the company as a commanding Witch and singles out Simbi Akande as a radiant Cinderella among the newcomers.

Read David Wootton’s full review at Plays International

Everything Theatre

Reviewer: Alice Grahame

Alice Grahame reads the show as a grown-up answer to the fairy tales parents pass on to their children: playful before the interval, far crueller after it. The reveal of Tom Scutt’s woods under Aideen Malone’s shafts of light is, for her, like walking into an illustrated picture book.

"Picking standout cast members is difficult amongst so many faultless performances."

She still names Gracie McGonigal’s Red Riding Hood, Simbi Akande’s Cinderella and Keith Ramsay’s Jack, enjoys the Princes’ Agony as a highlight and says Kate Fleetwood makes Last Midnight look easy. Her only caution is that Sondheim’s dissonant score can be an acquired taste.

Read Alice Grahame’s full review at Everything Theatre

musicOMH

"Fein’s magnificent West End transfer casts its spell at the Noël Coward Theatre"

Reviewer: Sam Smith

Writing from the classical desk, Sam Smith treats the woods as a place of danger and self-discovery, and finds that Jordan Fein’s staging fits its new proscenium home well. He credits the dense set, Jenny Ogilvie’s movement and the 12-strong band under Alex Beetschen.

"Laura Pitt-Pulford gave another standout performance as the Baker’s Wife"

He notes that not every singer shapes Sondheim’s rhymes with the same care, but judges the ensemble’s strengths well ahead of any weak spots, with Fleetwood’s Witch, the Princes’ Agony reprise and No One Is Alone among his high points.

Read Sam Smith’s full review at musicOMH

SeatPlan

"An ambitious and spellbinding production."

Reviewer: Laura Foulger

Laura Foulger is most taken with the design, crediting Tom Scutt’s set and Aideen Malone’s lighting with turning the forest into a place of real wonder. She picks out Gracie McGonigal’s Little Red Riding Hood and Kate Fleetwood’s Witch as the standouts of a strong company.

"These are woods you’ll want to get lost in; just remember to drop your breadcrumbs."

Her one reservation is that a few plot turns, the twist that sets up the second act among them, could land harder, but she treats it as a small complaint against the evening as a whole.

Read Laura Foulger’s full review at SeatPlan

South London Press

Reviewer: Christopher Peacock

Christopher Peacock asks whether a revival brings a new perspective or a dazzling spectacle, and decides that Scutt’s design and Malone’s lighting supply the magic here.

"Kate Fleetwood returns as the Witch with an enthralling turn."

He rates the singing of Akande and Pitt-Pulford as superb, finds the woods even more claustrophobic inside a proscenium arch, and recommends it to every Sondheim fan.

Read Christopher Peacock’s full review at South London Press

British Theatre Guide

Reviewer: Rebecca Clifton

Clifton, writing for a site that publishes no star ratings, praises the humour Jordan Fein finds and Tom Scutt’s enchanting woods, lit with menace by Aideen Malone, and singles out Gracie McGonigal, Kate Fleetwood, Laura Pitt-Pulford and the two princes.

"…it largely owes that to the stellar cast and Tom Scutt's set design."

The fast, vibrant first act is not matched by the second, which Clifton feels lulls, although the full-company numbers are the evening’s highlights.

Read Rebecca Clifton’s full review at British Theatre Guide

Curtain Call Reviews

Reviewer: Paul Wood

Wood finds that the proscenium house brings the company closer to the audience, though the smaller stage costs the woods some of the impact they had at the Bridge, and the second act leans too hard on haze to set the scene.

"This might not be a ground-breaking production but it is a good production of a great show…"

His standouts are Gracie McGonigal’s Little Red, Fleetwood’s Witch and the two Princes, and he has warm words for the 12-piece orchestra. His advice is to catch it while it is in the West End.

Read Paul Wood’s full review at Curtain Call Reviews

Production photographs by Johan Persson.

Also reviewed by: The Times (Dominic Maxwell, “I was bewitched by this Sondheim fairytale with a stunningly good witch”), and The Stage (Tom Wicker, five stars, “Better than ever”), whose reviews sit behind a paywall and a registration wall respectively.

For more on the production, see our opening-night production photographs and our guide to what to expect from Into the Woods.

Into the Woods is booking at the Noël Coward Theatre until 9 January 2027.