The Broadway cast recording of Two Strangers (Carry A Cake Across New York), the British two-hander first seen in London at the Kiln Theatre, is one of five albums shortlisted for Best Musical Theater Album at the 2027 Grammys, with Sam Tutty and writers Jim Barne and Kit Buchan among the first-time nominees.
A musical written in Britain and first seen at a modest north-west London playhouse now has a place at the Grammys. The Original Broadway Cast recording of Two Strangers (Carry A Cake Across New York) was named on 16 November among the five nominees for Best Musical Theater Album at the 2027 Grammy Awards, which the Recording Academy will present on 7 February 2027.
It is a first nomination for everyone credited on the album. Its two voices belong to Sam Tutty, who plays Dougal, and Christiani Pitts, who plays Robin; the score is by composer Jim Barne and lyricist Kit Buchan, and the recording was produced by Barne with Nick Finlow, the show's director Tim Jackson, and Lux Pyramid.
The road to that shortlist runs through English theatres. Barne and Buchan first drew notice with an earlier version of the piece, The Season, which won them The Stage Debut Award and the Stiles & Drewe prize for new musical theatre, and was co-produced by Royal & Derngate, Northampton and the New Wolsey Theatre, Ipswich. Reworked as Two Strangers, it sold out an extended ten-week run at the Kiln Theatre that ended in January 2024, then transferred to the Criterion Theatre that April, with Tutty opposite Dujonna Gift.
Tutty, who won an Olivier Award for Dear Evan Hansen, crossed the Atlantic with the show for his Broadway debut. The New York production opened at the Longacre Theatre in November 2025 and gives its final performance there on 29 November 2026, so the nomination arrives in the closing fortnight of the run.
The rest of the field is drawn entirely from Broadway, though it is not without British connections. Chess, nominated for its 2025 Broadway revival, has lyrics by Tim Rice and was first staged at the Prince Edward Theatre in 1986, and the nomination returns Benny Andersson to the category for the first time since 1989. The Lost Boys, the musical version of the 1987 vampire film, completes a list that also takes in the 2025 Broadway revival of Ragtime and the stage version of Schmigadoon!
The five nominees for Best Musical Theater Album are:
- CHESS the Musical (2025 Broadway Cast): principal vocalists Nicholas Christopher, Hannah Cruz, Bradley Dean, Lea Michele, Bryce Pinkham and Aaron Tveit; produced by Benny Andersson, Ludvig Andersson and Brian Usifer; music by Benny Andersson and Björn Ulvaeus, lyrics by Tim Rice
- The Lost Boys (Original Broadway Cast): principal vocalists Shoshana Bean, LJ Benet, Ali Louis Bourzgui, Paul Alexander Nolan, Benjamin Pajak and Maria Wirries; produced by Kyler England, Adrianne Gonzalez, Gabriel Mann and Ethan Popp; music and lyrics by Kyler England, Adrianne Gonzalez and Gabriel Mann
- Ragtime (2025 Broadway Cast): principal vocalists Colin Donnell, Joshua Henry, Caissie Levy, Nichelle Lewis, Ben Levi Ross and Brandon Uranowitz; produced by Lynn Ahrens, Sean Patrick Flahaven and Stephen Flaherty; music by Stephen Flaherty, lyrics by Lynn Ahrens
- Schmigadoon! (Schmigadoon! Original Broadway Company): principal vocalists Alex Brightman, Sara Chase and Ana Gasteyer; produced by Doug Besterman, David Chase, Cinco Paul and Scott M. Riesett; music and lyrics by Cinco Paul
- Two Strangers (Carry A Cake Across New York) (Original Broadway Cast): principal vocalists Christiani Pitts and Sam Tutty; produced by Jim Barne, Nick Finlow, Tim Jackson and Lux Pyramid; music by Jim Barne, lyrics by Kit Buchan
The Recording Academy has published the full list of 2027 nominations. There is nothing to book in London for now: the Criterion engagement closed in 2024.







